Why Is EMDR Therapy Controversial? Separating Myths from Science
If you’ve ever fallen down a late-night Google rabbit hole searching for therapy options, you’ve probably stumbled across EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing).
While it’s hailed as a transformative, evidence-based treatment for trauma, you might’ve also seen headlines questioning its effectiveness. So, what’s the deal? Why is EMDR controversial?
At Live Full Therapy in Nashville, we believe in both the power of EMDR and the importance of informed decision-making. That’s why we're here to demystify EMDR, break down the controversy, and share what the science actually says. Spoiler alert: It’s not as mysterious as you think.
What Is EMDR, Anyway?
Before we dive into the controversy, let’s get clear on what EMDR is. EMDR is a type of therapy designed to help people process and heal from traumatic experiences. EMDR utilizes the Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) Model, which posits that traumatic or distressing experiences can become stored in the brain in an unprocessed and maladaptive form, leading to psychological distress and symptoms. EMDR therapy uses bilateral stimulation, such as eye movements or tapping, to facilitate the brain's natural information processing system and allow the individual to access and properly store these unprocessed memories.
The goal? To reduce the emotional intensity of traumatic memories so they no longer cause intense distress. Think of it like “reorganizing” your brain’s filing cabinet—moving memories from the “emergency drawer” to a place where they’re stored safely without causing distress. Both your brain and body recognize that those things happened in the past and are not happening to you in the present. This leads to symptom reduction and a greater sense of well-being.
If you’re curious about how we use EMDR in practice, check out this page for more details.
Why Is EMDR Therapy Controversial?
Despite its growing popularity, EMDR has sparked debate in both clinical and public circles. Here’s why:
1. The Eye Movements Seem… Well, Weird
Let’s be honest—the idea of moving your eyes back and forth to process trauma sounds a little out there. This unusual technique often leads people to question its legitimacy. Critics argue that the eye movements are unnecessary and that the therapeutic effects come solely from standard exposure techniques used in other therapies.
What the Science Says:
Surprisingly, multiple studies support the role of bilateral stimulation. Research published in the Journal of Anxiety Disorders (Lee & Cuijpers, 2013) found that EMDR is as effective—if not more so—than traditional trauma therapies like Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), particularly in reducing PTSD symptoms. Bilateral stimulation may help the brain process memories similarly to what happens during REM sleep, promoting emotional regulation.
2. It Works Quickly—Almost Too Quickly
EMDR often yields significant results in fewer sessions compared to traditional talk therapy. For some, this raises eyebrows: “If it works that fast, is it really addressing the problem?”
What the Science Says:
Yes, EMDR can work quickly, but that doesn’t mean it’s superficial. A meta-analysis in the American Journal of Psychiatry (2017) confirmed that EMDR effectively reduces PTSD symptoms, even in shorter time frames. The efficiency is due to EMDR’s ability to target the root cause of distress directly, rather than just managing symptoms.
3. It’s Hard to Explain, and Even Harder to Measure…or is it?
In traditional therapy, progress is often measured through dialogue, behavior changes, or cognitive shifts. EMDR’s process from the outside might seem less tangible—however the same things can be measured as a result of EMDR. People who engage in EMDR therapy notice and report symptom reduction, cognitive shifts, behavior changes and a greater ability to navigate situations that used to feel overwhelming.
What the Science Says:
While EMDR may seem abstract, its outcomes are measurable. The World Health Organization (WHO) and the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs both recognize EMDR as an effective treatment for trauma and PTSD, supported by robust clinical trials.
Common Myths About EMDR—Debunked
🚫 Myth #1: EMDR is Hypnosis
Nope. EMDR doesn’t put you in a trance or alter your consciousness. You’re fully awake, aware, and in control throughout the session.
🚫 Myth #2: EMDR Only Works for PTSD
While EMDR is highly effective for PTSD, it’s also used to treat:
Anxiety and panic disorders
Phobias
Grief and loss
Chronic stress and low self-esteem
Many other common issues!
🚫 Myth #3: You Have to Relive Your Trauma in Detail
Unlike traditional exposure therapy, EMDR doesn’t require you to recount every detail of your traumatic experience. The focus is on processing the emotional impact, not retelling the story.
So… Does EMDR Actually Work?
Yes, it does. And we don’t just say that because we’re EMDR therapists—we say it because the evidence backs it up. A 2014 meta-analysis in The Journal of Clinical Psychology found EMDR to be highly effective for trauma, with lasting results.
At Live Full Therapy, we’ve seen EMDR transform lives—not because it’s a magical quick fix, but because it helps people process and heal in a way that feels safe, effective, and lasting.
What to Expect in an EMDR Session
If you’re considering EMDR but feeling unsure, here’s what the process typically looks like:
Initial Discussion: We get to know your history, goals, and concerns.
Preparation: We teach grounding and resourcing techniques to ensure you feel safe and supported. We’ll create a treatment plan that is tailored to what you want to address.
Reprocessing Phase: Using bilateral stimulation (like tapping or eye movements), we help your brain reprocess distressing memories.
Reflection: We discuss what came up, focusing on emotional shifts and insights.
Want to know more? Learn about our EMDR approach here.
Is EMDR Right for You?
While EMDR isn’t for everyone, it’s an incredible tool for many people struggling with trauma, anxiety, or distressing memories. The best way to find out? Talk to a therapist trained in EMDR (hint: that’s us!).
If you’re curious, skeptical, or somewhere in between, we’re here to help. No pressure, no judgment—just honest conversation about what’s best for you.
Ready to Demystify EMDR for Yourself?
You don’t have to navigate trauma or anxiety alone. At Live Full Therapy in Nashville, our EMDR-trained therapists are here to support your healing journey with compassion and expertise.
Schedule your free 20-minute consultation today to see if EMDR is the right fit for you.
CONNECT WITH A THERAPIST:
LIVE FULL THERAPY
Your neighborhood therapy practice in the heart of East Nashville. Offering a personalized and holistic approach to help you lead a more full and connected life.
GET IN TOUCH:
hello@livefulltherapy.com
2002 Eastland Ave, Unit 101
Nashville, TN 37206
